Paying for College: 529 or Roth IRA?
If college is a good fit for your kids, I’m sure you know all too well the conundrum of trying to save enough to pay for it. Unless you started when the tyke (or tykette) was born, the amount can be staggering. Frankly, when it comes to college, I encourage parents to save everything they can and keep an eye on loans, scholarships and grants down the road. 529s have become the vehicle of choice for many parents, but recently I’ve seen suggestions that a Roth IRA can be used effectively to pay for college. So, what’s the diff?
First, in most instances, money can be taken out tax-free from both a 529 and Roth. That won’t be the case with a 529, however, if money is used for “non college-related” expenses, like a trip or a car for Junior. With a Roth, you can take out your contributions, for any purpose, without tax or penalty. Advantage Roth. But for the earnings in a Roth, the sand starts shifting, particularly if the account owner is under the age of 59 1/2.
If you start taking money out and you’re under 59 1/2, all earnings will be taxable (until you become 59 1/2). So, if you had contributed, say, $50,000 to your Roth in 18 years, and good markets had pushed the account up to $125,000, you’d be able to take out the $50,000 tax-free, but that $75,000 in growth would all be taxable, no matter what you used the money for. If the same amounts had gone into a 529, it would all be available for college… tax-free. Advantage 529. How about this next factoid on financial aid to push your foot deeper into the sand: the effects of a 529 or Roth on financial aid.
According to http://www.savingsforcollege.com, “a 529 account owned by a parent for a dependent student is reported on the federal financial aid application (FAFSA) as a parental asset (emphasis added). Parental assets are assessed at a maximum 5.64% rate in determining the student’s Expected Family Contribution (EFC).” So, the fact that you’ve been a good dooby and saved for college will mean you won’t be eligible for quite as much financial aid, and that’s probably fair. But with a Roth, it’s worse. Not only could the Roth distributions all be taxable, but whatever you withdraw must be included in next year’s FAFSA application, again reducing Junior’s eligibility for financial aid. And using money from a grandparent’s Roth? That’s even worse, potentially reducing aid eligibility by more than 12%.
It could me my Midwestern roots, but when it comes to saving for college, I vote for the straightforward approach. Use a 529 to save for college, and keep your Roth earmarked for retirement. Good luck. Until next time, here’s to good planning!